Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 
©2009 *lucky-april
:iconlucky-april:

Artist's Comments

Model: Lucie

Good vs Evil
The choices we have to make, the things we must choose, how we can never stay neutral, and to hover between two for too long would be to not live...Will she choose the white wings, or the black?


Taken April 2009

Photo & Post-processing by me, in PhotoScape.

My submission to the Wacom Good vs Evil contest

Critiques


:iconmarshmallow-pies:
There is something so beautiful and moody in this. I really, really like this one, and I'm glad you've finally gotten some proper photos of Lucie! But on to the critique.

Vision:
It's eye-catching and gorgeous. The contrast in colors is very effective - red, white and black is always a good combination, and you used it effectively.
The slightly opened mouth and the way she's pulling that strap are so right for the message you're trying to put across, showing just the right amount of uncertainty. Also, I love what her hair is doing :]

Originality:
Sadly, wings are awesome, but there are so many photos with wings. It sometimes seems as if all the good ideas have already been used - we have very little margin for innovative thought!
However, you are doing something a bit newer with the wings; there's more of message to it than "oh, pretty girl looking like an angel", so you do have a bit more merit than the average artist working with wings!

Technique:
My biggest problem with the photo is probably the change in color of the wall. You know I love the wall, but I wish it weren't so drastically lighter on the right half. (Also, the white marks feel incongruous but there's not much you can do about that.)
Good focus and sharpness, and I like the light on her. In itself, it's a great portrait. The off-center composition was a great choice.
I can't help but feel that there's a bit of distortion in the image right now though - honestly, maybe try uploading it in PNG? They're heavier files, but JPG doesn't compress well.

Impact:
I love it! All the various elements come together to create a completely coherent whole (and check out that alliteration haha) - from Lucie's pose and expression, to the colors, to the composition, to the idea behind.
It may be a pretty photo of a pretty girl wearing pretty wings, but it's got soul as well.

Great work, well done, and good luck for the competition!
The Artist thought this was FAIR
6 out of 6 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconfoodshelf:
awesome, great pose and timing with the shot.
:iconlucky-april:
Thankyouu
Had good fun with that shoot. The wings are always a challenge to a new model! :)

--
Frenglish and proud :heart:
:iconcorrasion:
this is a great concept! the composition works really well :D

--
2+2=5.

wut?
Canadians don't live in igloos.

Want to read something? [link]
:iconlucky-april:
Thanks alot, I had something really particular in mind and I really like how this one turned out! :)

--
Frenglish and proud :heart:
:iconyouplaboom:
J'aime bien le concept, c'est un beau cliché !

--
¤~ Zip Zap Zop ~¤
:icongroovigyrl:
Beautiful colors and composition! I love the calrity and contrast. Well done!

Details

April 15
3.1 MB
83.7 KB
900×646

Statistics

7
27 [who?]
926 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Camera Data

NIKON CORPORATION
NIKON D40
10/2500 second
F/4.0
26 mm
200
Apr 15, 2009, 1:05:25 PM

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map